The Rising Case For ESOPs: A Powerful And Time-Tested Succession Alternative With Growing Support In Washington And The Private Sector – Employee Rights/ Labour Relations

FL

Foley & Lardner

More

Foley & Lardner LLP looks beyond the law to focus on the constantly evolving demands facing our clients and their industries. With over 1,100 lawyers in 24 offices across the United States, Mexico, Europe and Asia, Foley approaches client service by first understanding our clients’ priorities, objectives and challenges. We work hard to understand our clients’ issues and forge long-term relationships with them to help achieve successful outcomes and solve their legal issues through practical business advice and cutting-edge legal insight. Our clients view us as trusted business advisors because we understand that great legal service is only valuable if it is relevant, practical and beneficial to their businesses.

If you are a business owner, you may be overlooking one of the most powerful and time-tested succession and ownership transition tools available: the Employee Stock Ownership Plan (ESOP).

United States
Employment and HR

Article Insights

If you are a business owner, you may be overlooking one of the
most powerful and time-tested succession and ownership transition
toolsavailable: the Employee Stock Ownership Plan (ESOP).

ESOPs have long been attractive for their unique tax advantages
and ability to reward employees, while preserving a company’s
legacy. For example, in certain structures, such as a 100%
ESOP-owned S corporation, companies can operate largely free of
federal income tax, creating a powerful cash-flow advantage.
Certain owners can also defer, or even eliminate, capital gains tax
on the sale of their shares.

Despite these advantages, ESOP formation has slowed in recent
years, largely due to legal uncertainty and post-closing litigation
risk, particularly around valuation practices. That may be about to
change, as bipartisan efforts in Washington seek to lower barriers
and provide greater certainty, paving the way for a more
ESOP-friendly environment:

• Valuation Clarity and Reduced Litigation Risk:
  Key House and Senate committees have recently advanced bipartisan
  legislation that would create a statutory safe harbor for ESOP
  fiduciaries when determining whether a sale of private company
  stock to an ESOP is for “adequate consideration.”




• Greater Policy Influence for ESOPs: A separate
  bipartisan measure would add ESOP representatives to the Department
  of Labor’s ERISA Advisory Council.




• Keeping Businesses in Local Hands: Newly
  introduced legislation seeks to encourage ESOP formation as a tool
  to root companies in their communities and preserve homegrown
  enterprises.

While these proposals are not yet law, their advancement through
key House and Senate committees underscores the growing bipartisan
recognition that ESOPs strengthen domestic competitiveness,
safeguard jobs, build employee wealth, and promote long-term
economic resilience.

The private equity sector is taking note as well. Firms are
exploring partially or fully-owned ESOP structures to align
employee incentives, improve retention, and boost performance.
Initiatives like Ownership Works—co-founded by KKR—aim
to expand equity participation for rank-and-file employees across
portfolio companies, underscoring the mainstream embrace of
broad-based employee ownership.

The data for ESOP-owned companies also supports this momentum.
According to third party research, young adults at ESOP companies
have 92% higher median household net worth and 33% higher wage
income than peers at non-ESOP companies. Employees also stay
longer— ESOP companies have lower turnover, were three to
four times more likely to retain staff during COVID-19, and show
lower bankruptcy rates in economic downturns.

Key Takeaway for Business Owners: ESOPs are
regaining momentum as one of the most compelling, tax-efficient,
and legacy-preserving succession and ownership transition tools
available. If you are weighing the next steps for your business,
including a potential sale to a strategic buyer or private equity
firm, you should also consider an ESOP. This article provides an
overview of ESOPs and explains when an ESOP might be the right fit
for you and your company.

ESOP Overview

An ESOP is a tax-qualified retirement plan, similar to a 401(k),
that invests primarily in company stock. When an ESOP is formed,
the company’s existing shareholders typically sell their shares
to the ESOP’s trust established for the benefit of employees.
To facilitate the sale, the ESOP trust is typically funded through
a combination of company borrowing (bank or other lender financing)
and seller financing (notes and detachable warrants). Together,
these mechanisms provide the necessary financing to allow the ESOP
trust to pay fair market value for the shares.

Employees, through their participation in the ESOP, become
beneficial owners (not direct shareholders) of the company on a
“tax-advantaged basis,” meaning they do not recognize
taxable income when shares are allocated to their ESOP accounts.
Instead, tax is deferred until employees receive distributions from
the plan, typically at retirement.

Congress first recognized ESOPs in the Employee Retirement
Income Security Act of 1974, with further tax incentives added in
later legislation. Today, there are about 6,500 ESOPs covering more
than 15 million participants nationwide, distributing roughly $150
billion annually in benefits. Collectively, employees enrolled in
ESOPs across the country hold more than $1.3 trillion in retirement
wealth.

Key Tenets of an ESOP Formation Transaction

• Fair Market Value – Trustees, acting as
  the fiduciary on behalf of an ESOP, pay no more and no less than
  fair market value for shares, ensuring a market-based transaction
  in compliance with the tax rules that apply to qualified retirement
  plans.




• Significant Tax Advantages – Corporate
  and shareholder tax benefits can make after-tax proceeds
  competitive with, or even superior to, private equity or strategic
  sales:
  

  • S Corporation Exemption – ESOP-owned S
    corporations avoid federal and, in many cases, state income tax on
    their ESOP-owned share of earnings.

  
  

  • Section 1042 Rollover – Eligible C
    corporation shareholders can defer and potentially eliminate
    capital gains taxes by reinvesting ESOP transaction proceeds in
    “qualified replacement property.”

  
  

  • Corporate Tax Deductions – When a
    company establishes an ESOP, the ESOP trust typically
    “borrows” money from the company in what’s called an
    internal loan. The company gets that cash either from its own cash
    reserves or from outside bank financing, and then contributes it to
    the ESOP trust so the trust can buy the shares from the selling
    shareholders. When an ESOP borrows from the company in this way,
    the ESOP is known as a “leveraged” ESOP while the loan is
    outstanding. Each year, the company makes tax-deductible
    contributions to the ESOP, and the ESOP uses those contributions to
    pay down the internal loan. In practice, this creates a
    “double benefit”: the company gets a tax deduction for
    making the contributions to the ESOP, and those contributions are
    then used to retire the acquisition debt—improving cash flow
    compared to a taxable structure.




• Wealth Building for Employees – ESOPs
  put appreciating assets directly in the hands of workers. Unlike
  other tax-qualified defined contribution plans, like 401(k) plans,
  most ESOPs require no out-of-pocket contributions from employees.
  This means more workers gain ownership and valuable retirement
  savings benefits without having to stretch paychecks. Each year,
  eligible employees are allocated additional shares under their ESOP
  accounts as the ESOP loan is repaid. While the company does not
  reinvest dividends or compound returns in the traditional sense,
  the value of each share grows as the company grows. Over time, the
  combination of accumulating more shares and an increasing share
  price generates meaningful retirement wealth for employees.




• Higher Engagement and Retention –
  Ownership fosters a deeper connection to the company’s success.
  As a tax-qualified retirement plan, ESOPs are required to follow
  certain nondiscrimination and vesting rules under the tax code,
  which facilitate providing broad-based employee ownership in annual
  ESOP allocations and encouraging employee retention to fully vest
  in accrued benefits under the plan. ESOP structures consistently
  produce greater commitment, lower turnover and higher engagement.
  According to the ESOP Association, ESOP adoption is linked with 46%
  longer average tenure for employees and 80% of leaders report
  better recruitment and retention.




• A Culture of Continuous Improvement –
  Employee ownership fuels a shared drive for innovation and
  efficiency. ESOP companies routinely report that employees bring
  forward new ideas, seek process improvements and “row in the
  same direction” with a unified sense of purpose. According to
  the ESOP Association, ESOP companies are 1.4 times more likely to
  provide employee training than conventionally owned businesses,
  helping ensure the workforce remains skilled, engaged and
  future-ready.




• Financial and Operational Resilience –
  ESOP companies often take a long-term view, prioritizing
  sustainable growth over short-term gains. This mindset has helped
  many navigate downturns and emerge stronger. According to the ESOP
  Association, studies show ESOP-owned companies are 7.3 times less
  likely to lay off employees than conventional private companies,
  helping sustain local economies when times get tough.




• Legacy Preservation – Selling to an ESOP
  keeps ownership within the organization, minimizing cultural
  disruption and preserving brand and strategic direction.




• Structural Flexibility – ESOP
  transactions can be structured as partial or full sales (including
  a planned series of sales to increase ESOP ownership over time),
  tailored to shareholder needs and financed through combinations of
  company cash, senior bank debt, seller notes (often with detachable
  warrants), and mezzanine debt if needed. In practice, the company
  usually takes on debt—either (i) to redeem shares directly
  from shareholders and then contribute those shares over time to the
  ESOP trust for allocation to participants, or (ii) to contribute
  cash to the ESOP trust, which in turn uses that cash (through an
  internal loan) to purchase shares directly from shareholders. In
  either structure, shares are gradually allocated to participants
  over time. As the company pays down its debt, any warrants attached
  to selling shareholder notes typically increase in value as the
  business grows. This gives selling shareholders an additional
  potential upside for financing the ESOP transaction—often
  through lower-interest seller notes.

When an ESOP May Be the Right Fit

An ESOP may be especially compelling if you:

• Want liquidity without selling to a competitor or private
  equity firm.




• Seek flexibility in succession timing as ESOPs allow owners to
  sell all or part of their shares on their own schedule, providing
  control over exit planning.




• Seek to preserve your company’s culture, autonomy, and
  brand.




• Operate in industries with limited buyer interest, increased
  regulatory scrutiny, or headline risk.




• Have strong, stable cash flows and a capable leadership
  team.




• Prefer to transition ownership over time while remaining
  involved post-transaction.




• Wish to capture estate planning and tax benefits through
  creative structuring.

The content of this article is intended to provide a general
guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought
about your specific circumstances.